Anaesthesia Section DOI : 10.7860/JCDR/2015/12721.5866
Year : 2015 | Month : May | Volume : 9 | Issue : 5 Page : UC01 - UC03

Comparison of Efficacy of Clonidine versus Ondansetron for Prevention of Nausea and Vomiting Post Thyroidectomy: A Double Blind Randomized Controlled Trial

Setty Nagendra Gupta Shilpa1, Sampangiramaiah Shailaja2, Selvaraj Shanthini Hilda3

1Postgraduate Resident, Department of Anaesthesiology, Father Muller Medical College, Mangalore, India.
2Assistant Professor, Department of Anaesthesiology, Father Muller Medical College, Mangalore, India.
3Senior Resident, Department of Anaesthesiology, Father Muller Medical College, Mangalore, India.


NAME, ADDRESS, E-MAIL ID OF THE CORRESPONDING AUTHOR: Dr. Shailaja S, Assistant Professor, Department of Anaesthesiology, Father Muller Medical College, Mangalore-575002, India.
E-mail: drshaila@rediffmail.com
Abstract

Background and Aim

Postoperative nausea vomiting (PONV) is the most common symptom in patients post thyroidectomy. Literature search shows conflicting results regarding use of clonidine in PONV prophylaxis. We undertook this randomized controlled double blind trial to compare the efficacy of clonidine with dexamethasone versus ondansetron with dexamethasone for PONV prophylaxis in these patients.

Materials and Methods

In this prospective study, 60 condivutive patients posted for thyroidectomy from August 2013 to July 2014, were randomly assigned to two groups, ondansetron (N= 30) (Group A) and clonidine (N= 30) (Group B). Patients received either oral ondansetron 8mg or oral clonidine 150μg as premedication. At the end of surgery, both groups received dexamethasone 8mg intravenously. They were monitored for occurrence of PONV and sore throat for next 24 h. Ramsay sedation scores and total time of analgesia was noted. The primary end point was incidence of PONV in post operative for 24 h. Pearson’s chi square test and Students t tests were performed using SPSS for windows version 20 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL).

Results

Baseline characteristics of patients were comparable. A higher proportion of patients in clonidine group developed PONV than ondansetron (36.7% vs 30%; p=0.03). Clonidine group patients experienced early nausea and vomiting (1-2hrs of postoperative period), compared to ondansetron group patients (6-12 h). Ramsay sedation scores at arrival were higher in clonidine group compared to ondansetron group (2.1 ± 0.3 versus 2.0; p=0.003). Total time of analgesia was higher with use of clonidine than ondansetron (919.5 ± 622 mins versus 642 ± 631 mins; p=0.09). Moderate sore throat was seen in 2 out of 30 patients in both groups. No major adverse events were observed in either group.

Conclusion

Ondansetron with dexamethasone group was more effective in controlling PONV after thyroidectomy compared to clonidine with dexamethasone group. However, ramsay sedation scores and total time of analgesia were higher with clonidine than ondansetron.

Introduction

Post operative nausea and vomiting (PONV) is one of the most common and distressing symptom after surgery. The estimated incidence of PONV is 40- 60% [1,2]. Thyroidectomy is a high risk surgery with incidence of PONV of 60-84% [3]. The proposed risk factors for PONV in thyroid surgeries are vagal stimulation during surgical manipulation of neck, female gender, prolonged duration of surgery, volatile anaesthetics, nitrous oxide, large dose of neostigmine and opiods [3,4]. PONV following thyroid surgeries can exacerbate bleeding causing neck hematoma and potential airway obstruction and re-exploration of surgical site. Hence, there is need to prevent PONV.

Multimodal therapy is always better than monotherapy as the aetiology of PONV is multifactorial. Multimodal therapy than monotherapy is the recommendation for prevention of PONV in high risk patients. Various drug combinations have been tried and found to be effective [5-7].

Ondansetron a 5HT3 antagonist, is well established for prophylaxis of PONV as oral and intravenous preparation [1,7-9]. Clonidine an α2 adrenergic agonist is extensively used as premedication. It is a sedative, suppresses cardiovascular response to laryngoscopy, reduces anaesthetic requirement and used for induced hypotension during anaesthesia, however there are few reports of oral clonidine usage for PONV [10,11]. Dexamethasone has been combined with other drugs when used for prophylaxis of PONV [9].

We hypothesized that use of two drugs having different mechanisms of action would lead to reduction in incidence of PONV. Hence, we performed this randomized double blind controlled study to evaluate the efficacy and safety of combination of oral clonidine with hilda3intravenous dexamethsone versus oral ondansetron with intravenous dexamethsone for prevention of PONV after thyroidectomy.

Materials and Methods

After obtaining clearance from institutional ethical committee the trial was registered with Clinical Trial registry of India no CTRI/2014/01/004345. Written informed consent obtained from 60 patients posted for thyroidectomy between August 2013 to July 2014 of ASA I and ASA II aged between 18-60 y of either sex were included in study. Patients on adrenoreceptor agonists or antagonists, known hypersensitivity to anaesthetics, uncontrolled diabetes mellitus, pregnancy, ASA 3 and above, on perioperative anti emetics, steroids, antihistamine or psychiatric drugs and refusal to participate in the study were excluded.

Based on the previous study the incidence of PONV is 40%, we were interested in decreasing the incidence of PONV, with intervention. Taking power of 80% and significance level of 5%, a sample size of 30 per group was decided. A pre-anaesthetic check was done in all patients with a detailed history and routine lab investigations. The type of surgery planned and thyroid profile were noted. Patients were kept nil per oral overnight. Diazepam 5mg and ranitidine 150mg were given as premedication in the night before surgery to all patients in the protocol. We have followed CONSORT guidelines of RCT. Randomization of the patients were done in the pre-operative period after meeting all the inclusion and exclusion criteria. The block randomization was done with block size of 10. An independent statistician using computer generated random number table did sequence generation. Allocation concealment was done using sequentially numbered opaque sealed envelopes. Consent obtained by one of the three authors and assigning the patients to either of the treatment groups as per the randomization sequence and administration of the drugs was done by an independent anaesthesiologist not involved in the study. The study investigators and the patients were blinded to the study treatment through identical vials and tablets coded as A & B in the two groups respectively. Patients assigned to Group A (N= 30) were premedicated with Tab ondansetron 8mg orally and those to Group B (N= 30) received tab clonidine 150μg orally one hour before surgery.

Standard anaesthesia technique was followed using thiopentone sodium 5 mg/kg, fentanyl 2μg/kg, and intubated after administration of succinycholine 1.5mg/kg. They were maintained intraoperatively with isoflurane 0.6-1-5% and 66% nitrous oxide in oxygen. Neuromuscular relaxation was achieved with vecuronium. All patients received Inj dexamethasone 8mg IV before closure of muscle layer and patient reversed with neostigmine 0.05mg/kg and glycopyrrolate 0.01mg/kg. Duration of surgery was noted.

For the study PONV- defined as an episode of nausea, retching (involuntary attempt to vomit without expulsion of stomach contents), and vomiting (actual expulsion of stomach contents) was noted. As clonidine is known for its sedative action and used as premedication in this study, Ramsay sedation score (modified) was noted at arrival and in the postoperative period. Its sedative effect was helpful as premedication in patients with anxiety. Sedation score (modified Ramsay) was noted at on arrival to operation theatre and in the postoperative period [Table/Fig-1].

Statistical Aanalysis

Descriptive statistics were expressed as Mean±SD or number (%). Numerical variables were compared between groups by students t-test. Categorical variables were compared by Pearson’s chi-square test. All statistical tests were performed using SPSS for Windows version 20 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). All analysis was two tailed. A p-value <0.05 implies statistical significance.

Results

After careful assessment, a total of 60 patients fulfilling the inclusion and exclusion criteria were prospectively enrolled from August 2013 to July 2014 and were randomized; 30 patients were assigned to the ondansetron group and 30 patients to clonidine group. The two study groups were well-matched with respect to demographic characteristics, clinical and laboratory data [Table/Fig-2].

In the total of 60 patients, 33.3% (20/60) developed PONV. Out of these, 30% (9/30) were in ondansetron group and 36.7% (11/30) in clonidine group. The need for rescue antiemetic was also statistically significant between the groups (p=0.03). Patients in clonidine group had PONV within one hour after surgery and ondansetron group had PONV in between 6-12 hrs after surgery [Table/Fig-3]. The modified Ramsay sedation scores were significantly higher on arrival in clonidine group as compared to ondansetron group (2.1 ± 0.3 versus 2.0; p=0.003). However, no significant difference was seen in the sedation scores between two groups in post-operative period (2.9 ± 0.3 versus 2.9 ± 0.4; p=0.15) respectively. Moderate sore throat was seen equally in both groups, that is 2 out of 30 patients in each group.

Time of Analgesia

The time for use of rescue analgesic in post operative period was more prolonged in clonidine group as compared to ondansetron group (919.5 ± 622 min versus 642 ± 631 min) but it was not statistically significant (p=0.09). Heart rate and blood pressure increased during laryngoscopy and tracheal intubation in both the groups and the changes were comparable between them. Side effects like bradycardia is seen in clonidine group (2/0) and headache is seen in ondansetron group (2/0) [Table/Fig-2]. Bradycardia responded to injection atropine and patients with headache were treated with injection diclofenac 75mg IM.

Discussion

Postoperative nausea and vomiting is a distressing side effect in thyroidectomy patients. If not effectively prevented, it can lead to higher post operative morbidity and prolonged hospitalization resulting in increased health care cost. PONV is the second cause for readmission after day-care surgery [2].

Multifactorial aetiology of PONV is better addressed by multimodal approach. Enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) society and meta-analysis trials recommends ondansetron and dexamethasone combination is ideal for prophylaxis of PONV in moderate to high risk patients [12]. The present study showed that 30% in ondansetron group and 36.7% in clonidine group experienced PONV, which was comparable to Eun Jim Kim study in which PONV reduced from 80% to 33% [13].

Dexamethasone is a glucocorticoid known for its antiemetic activity in chemotherapy patients. It is both centrally and peripherally acting. In central nervous system, it regulates neurotransmitter levels, receptor densities and neurone configuration in nuclei which are known to have significant effect on nausea and vomiting [14,15]. In thyroid patients, oedema and inflammation around the neck tissues may sustain evoked parasympathetic impulses through vagus, recurrent laryngeal and glossopharyngeal nerve to the vomiting centre. Dexamethasone reduce tissue inflammation and reduce the ascending parasympathetic impulses to the vomiting centre [16]. Wide range of single dose is used (8-32mg), most commonly 8mg, but optimal dose is yet to be defined. Jaleel F, Basanth Bhattarai and Ming Shan Chen in their studies have shown that dexamethasone have shown good prophylactic effect for PONV when given one hour prior to surgery or beginning of surgery [17-19]. Three randomized controlled studies on timing of dexamethasone have demonstrated that no significant statistical difference between timing of giving in beginning or end of surgery [16,17,20]. Hence, we administered dexamethasone at the end of surgery.

Ondansetron is a 5HT3 antagonist. According to the Society for Ambulatory Anaesthesia [12], 16mg ondansetron is suggested one hour before the surgery as a prophylaxis for PONV and it also suggests that repeat dose is essential after 6 h after the first dose. The results in our study support this evidence, as majority of patients in ondansetron group had PONV 6-12 h after the surgery.

Clonidine is an alpha 2 agonist known for its utility in induced hypotensive anaesthesia. In some studies it has shown antiemetic effect when used as premedication [10,11,21]. Clonidine is known for other beneficial effects in anaesthesia with low cost of drug which has onset of action 0.5-1 h and longer duration of action of upto 12h [22]. Moreover, it has been reported to reduce shivering and PONV when administered systemically and epidurally [23]. Oddby-Muhrbeck et al., [21] showed that clonidine reduced PONV from 73.33% in placebo group to 40%, which is comparable to our study. Tehari A [10], in his study, on patients posted for ear surgery found that clonidine reduced PONV from 66.6% to 33% which is also comparable to our study. Important side effects of clonidine are bradycardia and hypotension. In our study, only 2 out of 30 patients needed atropine for bradycardia.

Ramsay sedation score

ScoreClinical condition
1Awake and anxious, agitated, or restless
2Awake, cooperative, accepting ventilation, oriented, tranquil
3Awake; responds only to commands
4Asleep; brisk response to light glabellar tap or loud noise
5Asleep; sluggish response to light glabellar tap or loud noise stimulus but does not respond to painful stimulus
6Asleep; no response to light glabellar tap or loud noise

Demographic data and baseline characteristics in the two groups Expressed in mean ± SD (Group A- Ondansetron, Group B-Clonidine)

ParameterGroup A (n- 30) Mean ± SD OndansetronGroup B (n- 30) Mean ± SD Clonidinep-value
Age (in y)43.5 ±11.339.5 ± 9.90.41
Female/male gender27/327 /31.0
Weight (in kg)56.7 ± 8.355.8 ± 7.70.36
Thyroid function tests
T3(μg/dl)1.3 ± 0.31.1 ± 0.30.2
T4(μg/dl)7.3 ± 2.46.2 ± 2.50.9
TSH(uU/ml)1.4 ±1.11.8 ± 2.20.31
Duration of surgery (in min)151 ± 42.9143.5 ± 57.50.66
Heart rate (beats/minute)75. 57 ± 11.575.3 ± 9.690.16
Systolic blood pressure (mm of Hg)125.8 ± 13.49129.4 ± 13.850.57
Diastolic blood pressure (mm of Hg)80.5 ± 7.5183.2 ± 7.420.98

Clinical observations during study process between two groups

ParameterGroup A (n- 30) Mean ± SD OndansetronGroup B (n- 30) Mean ± SD Clonidinep-value
PONVImmediate1.83 ± 0.371.8 ± 0.40.513
1 h1.93 ± 0.251.77 ± 0.430.0*
3 h1.96 ± 0.181.93 ± 0.250.242
6 h1.93 ± 0.252.00.03**
12 h1.96 ± 0.182.00.043
Modified Ramsay sedation scoresArrival22.1 ± 0.30.003
Postop2.9 ± 0.42.9 ± 0.30.15
Sore throatMild111
Moderate27271
Severe221
Rescue analgesia (in mins)642 ± 631919.5 ± 6220.9
Rescue antiemetic1.76 ± 0.41.63 ± 0.50.03
Headache020.492***
Bradycardia requiring atropine200.492***

*clonidine group patients had maximum nausea and vomiting in the 1st postoperative hour compared to ondansetron group, statistically significant.

**ondansetron group had PONV more compared to clonidine after 6hrs of surgery, statistically significant.

***Headache was more in ondansetron and Bradycardia was more in clonidine group. Which are statistically significant


Limitations

The possible limitations in the study were, it was a single centre study including a small group of patients and monitored only for 24h. The outcome of the study was quite gratifying as the results strongly indicate that probably this protocol based treatment can modulate the post operative course in a proportion of patients post thyroidectomy. This is probably the first randomized controlled double blind trial which compared oral clonidine with dexamethasone versus oral ondansetron with dexamethasone. We did not include a placebo group due to ethical reasons.

Conclusion

Oral clonidine with intravenous dexamethasone was less effective than oral ondansetron with intravenous dexamethasone in counteracting PONV following thyroidectomy surgery. Clonidine group experienced early PONV while ondansetron group had late onset of PONV. However, combination of oral ondansetron with dexamethsone or oral clonidine with dexamethasone reduced the overall incidence of PONV in thyroidectomy patients. Ramsay sedation scores were high in clonidine group on arrival to operation theatre however no difference in scores between two groups in postoperative period. Time of first analgesic in clonidine group is more compared to ondansetron group. None of the patients in either group experienced sorethroat while some patients in ondansetron had headache and in clonidine group 2 patients needed atropine for bradycardia.

*clonidine group patients had maximum nausea and vomiting in the 1st postoperative hour compared to ondansetron group, statistically significant.**ondansetron group had PONV more compared to clonidine after 6hrs of surgery, statistically significant.***Headache was more in ondansetron and Bradycardia was more in clonidine group. Which are statistically significant

References

[1]MR Tramer, DJ Reynolds, RA Moore, HJ McQuay, Efficacy, dose–response, and safety of ondansetron in prevention of postoperative nausea and vomiting: a quantitative systematic review of randomized placebo-controlled trials Anesthesiology 1997 87(6):1277-89.  [Google Scholar]

[2]MF Watcha, PF White, Postoperative nausea and vomiting. Its aetiology, treatment, and prevention Anesthesiology 1992 77(1):162-84.  [Google Scholar]

[3]M James, MD Sonner, M James, MD Hynson, JA Katz, Nausea and vomiting following thyroid and parathyroid surgery Journal of Clinical Anesthesia 1997 9(5):398-402.  [Google Scholar]

[4]J Gan Tong, Risk Factors For Postoperative nausea and vomiting Anaesthesia and Analgesia 2006 102(6):1884-98.  [Google Scholar]

[5]PE Scuderi, RL James, L Harris, GR III Mims, Multimodal antiemetic management prevents early postoperative vomiting after outpatient laparoscopy Anesth Analg 2000 91(6):1408-14.  [Google Scholar]

[6]Italian Group for Antiemetic Research. Dexamethasone, granisetron, or both for the prevention of nausea and vomiting during chemotherapy for cancer N Engl J Med 1995 332:1-5.  [Google Scholar]

[7]LL Lopez-Olaondo, F Carrascosa, FJ Pueyo, P Monedero, N Busto, A Saez, Combination of ondansetron and dexamethasone in the prophylaxis of post-operative nausea and vomiting Br J Anaesth 1996 76(6):835  [Google Scholar]

[8]P Scuderi, B Wetchler, YF Sung, M Mingus, S DuPen, L Claybon, Treatment of postoperative nausea and vomiting after outpatient surgery with the 5-HT3 antagonist ondansetron Anesthesiology 1993 78(1):15-20.  [Google Scholar]

[9]J Lesser, H Lip, Prevention of nausea and vomiting using ondansetron, a new, selective, 5HT3 receptor antagonist Anesth Analg 1997 72(6):751-55.  [Google Scholar]

[10]A Taheri, MA Javadimanesh, H Ashraf, The effect of oral clonidine premedication on nausea and vomiting after ear surgery MEJ Anesth 2010 20(5):691-94.  [Google Scholar]

[11]N Gulhas, A Turkoz, M Durmus, T Togal, W Gedik, Mo Ersoy, Oral clonidine premedication does not reduce postoperative vomiting in children undergoing strabismus surgery Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2003 47(1):90-93.  [Google Scholar]

[12]TJ Gan, TA Meyer, CC Apfel, F Chung, PJ Davis, AS Habib, Society for Ambulatory Anesthesia Guidelines for the Management of Postoperative Nausea and Vomiting International Anesthesia Research Society 2007 105(6):1615-28.  [Google Scholar]

[13]EJ Kim, JS Ko, DH Choi, Combinations of Antiemetics for the Prevention of PONV in high risk patients. J Korean Med Sci 2007 22(5):878-82.  [Google Scholar]

[14]M Morimoto, N Morita, H Ozawa, K Yokoyama, M Kawata, Distribution of glucocorticoid receptor immunoreactivity and mRNA in the rat brain: an immunohistochemical and in situ hybridization study. Neurosci Res 1996 26(3):235-69.  [Google Scholar]

[15]JW Funder, Mineral corticoid receptors and glucocorticoid receptors. Clin Endocrinol 1996 45(6):651-56.  [Google Scholar]

[16]CV Feo, D Sortini, R Ragazzi, M Pe Perma, A Liboni, Randomized clinical trial of the effect of preoperative dexamethasone on nausea and vomiting after laparoscopic cholecystectomy Br J Surg 2006 93(3):295-99.  [Google Scholar]

[17]J Farhat, J Riffat, IA Mohammad, Efficacy and timing of single dose Dexamethasone as prophylactic Antiemetic in major surgeries Journal of Surgery Pakistan 2009 14(2):48-52.  [Google Scholar]

[18]B Battarai, S Shrestha, J Singh, Comparision of ondansetron and combination of ondansetron and dexamethasone as a prophylaxis for postoperative nausea and vomiting in adults undergoing elective laparoscopic surgery J Emerg Trauma Shock 2011 4(2):168-72.  [Google Scholar]

[19]M Chen, C Hong, H Chung, PC Peter, C Tsai, SU Han-Hsiang, Dexamethasone Effectively Reduces Postoperative Nausea and Vomiting in A General Surgical Adult Patient Population Chang Gung Med J 2006 29(2):175-80.  [Google Scholar]

[20]ST Ho, JJ Wang, JI Tzeng, HS Leu, LP Ger, Dexamethasone prophylaxis of nausea and vomiting associated with epidural morphine: A dose regimen Study Anesth Analg 1999 89(1):117-20.  [Google Scholar]

[21]E Oddby-Muhrbeck, S Eksborg, HT Bergendahl, O Muhrbeck, PA Lonngvist, Effects of clonidine on postoperative nausea and vomiting in breast cancer surgery Anesthesiol 2002 96(5):1109-14.  [Google Scholar]

[22]K Mikawa, K Nishina, N Maekawa, H Obara, Oral Clonidine Premedication Reduces Postoperative Pain in Children Anesth Analg 1996 82(2):225-30.  [Google Scholar]

[23]M Johr, Clonidine in Pediatric anaesthesia Eur J Anaesthesiology 2011 28(5):325-26.  [Google Scholar]