Community Medicine Section DOI : 10.7860/JCDR/2014/8595.4706
Year : 2014 | Month : Aug | Volume : 8 | Issue : 8 Page : JC01 - JC04

A Study on Morbidity Profile and Associated Risk Factors in a Rural Area of Dehradun

Shaili Vyas1, SD Kandpal2, Jayanti Semwal3, Deepshikha4

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Community Medicine, HIMS, SRH University, Dehradun, India.
2 Professor, Department of Community Medicine, SRH University, Dehradun, India.
3 Professor & HOD, Department of Community Medicine, HIMS, SRH University, Dehradun, India.
4 Assistant Professor, Department of Community Medicine, HIMS, SRH University, Dehradun, India.


NAME, ADDRESS, E-MAIL ID OF THE CORRESPONDING AUTHOR: Dr. Shaili Vyas, C-1/1, HIMS Campus, Jolly Grant, Dehradun, Uttarakhand, India Phone : 9759135362, E-mail : Shailivyas7@gmail.com
Abstract

Background: First few years of life is the most crucial period of life as this age is known for accelerated growth and development, warranting regular monitoring. During this period about 40% of physical growth and 80% of mental development occurs. Any adverse influences during this period may result in severe limitations in their development.

Methods: A cross-divtional study was conducted in the field practice area of Rural Health Training Centre. Mothers of children between 0-3 years of age were enquired about the morbidity in the past two months.

Results: Diarrhea (47.9%) followed by ARI (22.21%), Pica (13%) and Worm Infestation (9.21%) were the commonest morbidities found in the study population. Morbidities were found to be common in males as compared to females. Amongst the nutritional deficiencies anaemia & Vitamin B deficiencies were the commonest.

Conclusion: There was considerable sickness load amongst the toddlers. Morbidity can be reduced by improvement in the health care system at peripheral level

Introduction

The first few years of life is the most crucial period of life as this age is known for accelerated growth and development, warranting regular monitoring [1]. Any adverse influences during this period may result in severe limitations in their development [2]. It is well recognised that preschool children are nutritionally vulnerable segment of the population, also very susceptible to morbidity due to infections [3]. This age group is most affected by various common and easily treatable illnesses [2]. Prevalence, severity and frequency of morbidity due to infections depend upon infant and young child feeding and caring practices, nutritional status of the child, and environmental hygiene. Effect of morbidity on nutritional status depends upon severity and duration of infection, health care provided, feeding during illness and convalescence [3]. The population characteristics in rural area like socio-cultural variation, low socio economic status, poor health care utilization and over all compromised living condition make the rural children susceptible for various diseases. It is seen that malnutrition is more common in hilly areas than other parts of the country as majority of the children living in rural hilly areas are deprived of proper supply of food. Although, studies have been conducted on health problems among preschool children in India, there are still several localities for which epidemiological information is not available. Keeping in view, an attempt was made to assess the pattern of morbidities in toddlers residing in rural areas of Uttarakhand and to assess the health care utilization by their parents for the same.

Objectives

To study the morbidity status of under-three children.

To determine the association between various risk factors and morbidity profile.

To assess the treatment seeking behaviour of their parents during illness.

Methods

The present cross-sectional study was conducted in children below three years of age from eight villages of Rural Health Training Centre (RHTC), under the administrative control of Department of Preventive and Social Medicine, Himalayan Institute of Medical Sciences Dehradun, India. Duration of the study was from 1st May 2009 to 30th April 2010. A list of households having the study subjects from all the eight villages under RHTC was prepared & a total of 789 under three children were enlisted from these eight villages. The estimated sample size was calculated according to the formula: N=4pq/d2 where p is the prevalence of malnutrition, q=1-p, and d is relative error. Taking malnutrition as a proxy indicator for morbidities,the prevalence of malnutrition in children under three years of age was found to be p=45.9% [4] and relative precision d as 10 % of p, the sample size was calculated to be 468. Considering a no-response rate of 5% it was estimated to be 491 & hence the sample size was rounded off to 500 children.

To conduct this study, a predesigned pretested structured questionnaire was developed and all the questions were framed keeping the study objectives in mind to obtain the necessary information.This questionnaire was tested with a pilot study of 50 mothers of the same area, who had children less than three years of age. The researcher herself interviewed the mothers at the time of pilot testing. The objective of this pilot study was to test the data collection tool’s wording, as well as the clarity of stated questions & hence, reliability of these questions were checked in the pilot study and suitable modifications were made, before finally administering them to respondents.

A door–to–door survey was conducted and households with at least one infant below three years were selected. Taking the inclusion/exclusion criteria into account i.e. infants of multiple births defects, children who were absent for atleast three consecutive visits, parents who did not gave consent, or the child was uncooperative during clinical examination or while taking anthropometry, incomplete questionnaire, families with more than one child, in 0-3 years age group, only the younger child was selected for the present study. Hence, a total of 500 children were covered from these eight villages. Verbal informed consent was obtained from each of the mother and they were reassured that the information obtained will be confidential and used only for the purpose of this study.

An informed consent was taken prior to the interview and mothers were assured of the maintenance of confidentiality of their given information. After ensuring the confidentiality and building a rapport, in depth interview of mothers was undertaken and information regarding child’s age, sex, immunization status etc. was collected. Ages of most of the children were also estimated and cross-checked with reference to the local events such as some important festivals, siblings in the family, horoscopes etc. Information on the occurrence of any illness the child had in the preceding three months was obtained on recall basis. Morbidity Profile was taken keeping in mind the important under five illnesses (diarrhea, URTI, measles), along with history of Pica & worm infestation. The mother’s queries and doubts regarding the same were also answered for ethical reasons. Thereafter, clinical examination was done. Weight was measured using Salter spring balance for children who could not stand and Electronic weighing machine was used for older children. Height was measured without shoes to the nearest 0.1cm using calibrated Stadiometer. For children less than two years of age an Infantometer was used to measure the height. Nutritional status was assessed as per the growth chart developed by WHO using New WHO standards (MGRS 2006), with the help of Anthropometric calculator (Version 2.0.2) [5]. The signs for nutritional deficiencies were also noted in all children. The influence of different child related factors on the morbidity profile of children like immunization and nutritional status were analyzed using appropriate statistical tests. To keep a check on validity of the data, 10% of it was cross checked. Whole process of data collection was monitored by independent observers and supervised by the investigator. The information thus obtained was compiled, tabulated andanalyzed statistically to draw out observationsand meaningful conclusions. Chi-square test was applied as and where found appropriate. For the purpose of the study, morbidity was classified into three categories:

Acute diarrheal disease: defined as at least three watery stools in a 24h period, being considered a new episode if there was a 48h symptom-free interval.

Acute respiratory illness: defined as running nose or cough either with or without fever lasting for at least 72h.

Other morbidities included history of pica, worm infestation etc.

Inclusion criteria: All under-three children including neonates, except those meeting the exclusion criteria were included in the study.

Exclusion criteria: Pre-term newborn, congenital anomalous child and severely ill child were excluded from the study.

Fully Immunized children: An infant who has received BCG; three doses of DPT, OPV and and measles before one year of age.

Results

During the study period, a total of 500 under three children were surveyed for the pattern of illnesses. Diarrhea (47.9%) followed by ARI (22.21%), Pica (13%) and Worm Infestation (9.21%) were the commonest morbidities found in the study population [Table/Fig-1]. There were a total of 869 acute spells of sickness & hence, each child suffered with almost 3 illnesses per child. Morbidities were found to be common in males as compared to females [Table/Fig-2]. The overall prevalence of sparse hair was found to be 1.2%, dispigmentation of hair (0.6%), easy pluckability of hair (0.2%) & muscle wasting (0.8%) respectively. Vitamin A deficiency (conjunctival xerosis) was reported at 0.4%, while night blindness and bitot’s spot were not present. Vitamin B complex deficiency, mainly angular stomatitis, cheilosis and glossitis had a higher prevalence (10.8% of glossitis, 6.4% of angular stomatitis and 5.8% of cheilosis) [Table/Fig-3]. 85.6% of the study population was completely immunized and only 22(4.40) of the children did not receive any vaccine. Morbidity was found to be higher (75%) in children who were unimmunized as compared to those who were fully immunized (48.8%) [Table/Fig-4]. Further, it was seen that the preference to seek treatment in the govt. hospitals was higher (57.6%) than other facilities [Table/Fig-5].

Morbidity profile of study subjects

Sexwise morbidity pattern among the study subjects

VariableDistribution of childrenTotal
MaleFemale
Diarrhoea**215(51.68)201(48.32)416
ARI**108(55.96)85(44.04)193
Undernourished153(51.34)145(48.66)298
Measles32(51.61)30(48.39)62
History of Worm infestation/ Perianal itching43(53.75)37(46.25)80
History of Pica60(53.10)53(46.90)113
Dental caries3(60)2(40)5
Total6145531167

*History of Diarrhoea & ARI has been taken for the past 3 months #Multiple responses were obtained


Prevalence of nutritional deficiency signs

Clinical SignsNo of ChildrenFrequency
Signs of Protein Energy Malnutrition -14(2.8)
a)Sparse hairs61.2
b)Dispigmentation of hair30.6
c)Easy pluckability of hair10.2
d)Muscle wasting40.8
Vitamin A deficiency-2(0.4)
a)Night Blindness + Bitot’s spots20.4
Vitamin B-Complex deficiency - 115(23.0)
a)Angular Stomatitis326.4
b)Cheilosis295.8
c)Glossitis5410.8
Rickets-2(0.4)
Bowlegs +knock knees20.4
Anaemia12224.4

Distribution of morbidity on the basis of nutritional status & immunization

Type of SubjectTotal childrenMorbidities
PresentAbsent
Nutritional status
Well Nourished20285(42.1)117(57.9)
UnderNourished298178(59.7)120(40.3)
X2= 14.35 df=1 p= <0.001
Immunization Status
Complete428219(48.8)209(51.2)
Partial/Unimmunized5054(75)18(25)
X2= 15.89 df=1 p= <0.001

Treatment seeking behavior during Illness

Discussion

Diarrhoeal diseases were number one morbidities in children during 1990s and Acute respiratory infections in 2000s as revealed by different authors whereas in the current study, diarrhea (47.9%) remains as number one morbidity followed by ARI (22.21%), Pica (13%) and Worm Infestation (9.21%) [6]. Our findings are in line with several other authors like Kapil et al., Grover et al., and Panda et al., where diarrhoeal diseases were found to be the major cause of morbidity in the children, whereas our findings lay in contrast with several other studies by Patnaik et al., Biswas T et al., & Raj et al., [611]. The prevalence of diarrhea (47%) was comparable to rural villages of South Pakistan (51%) but was much higher as reported previously from West Bengal ( 31.67%) [1213]. The higher prevalence of diarrhea may be due to the harmful effects of poor hygiene and practice of open-field defecation. Direct comparison of findings between different studies is difficult because of differences in study design, study populations, timing & regional differences.

The mean number of episodes per child per year observed in the present study was higher than the figures of Gulati PV (2.44 episodes per child per year), and Muhe (2.34 episodes per child per year) [1415]. The mean number of episodes observed is far less than that observed by Gupta KB (10.7 episodes /child/ year) & P Gladstone where a very high morbidity with an average of 11 illnesses each year was reported during the first three years of life [1617]. The possible reasons for varying number of episodes in different studies could be differing geographic and climatic conditions.

In the current study, episodes of Diarrhoea, ARI & measles were more common in males as compared to females. Our findings are in contrast to a study by Goswami M et al., in Ahmedabad & by Marimuthu P et al., at Delhi slum where majority of the females were either suffering from or have ahistory of one or more illness within the previous two weeks [1819].

Reflections of poor nutritional status were also observed through high prevalence of PEM, vitamin B complex, and other nutritional deficiencies among preschool children. Vitamin B complex deficiency, had a higher prevalence compared to other nutritional deficiency signs, which might be due to the influence of socio-economic and environmental factors. This may be because of the fact that diet was deficient in pulses and green leafy vegetables, and hence the deficiency of vitamins was apparent.

Malnutrition and Infection goes hand in hand. Various studies have shown that the immunological response in PEM is impaired, Immune mechanism of the body also goes down and hence child becomes more vulnerable for infection thus PEM and infection forms a vicious cycle. The present study also found a significant association between morbidity and nutritional status. Similarly, in Aligarh, presence of measles, vitamin deficiency and worm infestation were significantly associated with malnutrition [20]. Another study in Banaras by Kavita et al., also showed that illness like diarrhea, worms in stool, URTI, had higher incidence in PEM children as compared to Non-PEM children [21]. Further, during illness partial or complete restriction of solid foods in the diet, which if repeatedly followed with recurrence of episodes is likely to affect the nutrition of the child. The cumulative effect of all these factors associated with loss of appetite and increased requirement during illness leads to varying grades of PEM.

The immunization status of the study population was good. The coverage of the vaccines was in general comparable to that reported for migrant tribal children in slums of Orissa, but poorer compared to the studies from Chandigarh and Madhya Pradesh [2224]. Morbidity was found to be higher (75%) in children who were unimmunized as compared to those who were fully immunized (48.8%) as the unimmunized children are at risk of developing these infections similarly, a significant association was found between ARI and Immunization by Pore at Solapur which is also quoted by various other authors [2527]. It was observed that preference to seek treatment in the govt. hospitals was higher (57.6%) than other facilities. Treatment of the child by local indigenous practitioners was another preferred treatment observed in the study area which prolonged the course of illness.

Conclusion

Morbidities like diarrhea, respiratory diseases, anaemia, under nutrition, various vitamin deficiencies among under three children in the present study was very common.The underutilization of the Government Health facility was also quite evident. These preliminary findings indicate that there is a need to improve utilization of Primary health care services including the vital MCH services for better child health and survival. The regrettable side to the issue is that most of the morbidities are largely preventable by simple interventions like immunization, adequate nutrition promotion of hygienic practices, through proper health education to their parents. Community health workers should also be trained adequately so that they are able to pick up signs of illness and encourage people in the community to seek treatment. Micronutrient supplementation and health education of the caregivers through simple health packages would go a long way in alleviating the co-morbidities.

*History of Diarrhoea & ARI has been taken for the past 3 months #Multiple responses were obtained

References

[1]Joshi S, Child survival, Health & Social work intervention(1996) New DelhiConcept publishing company  [Google Scholar]

[2]IMCI Information. Management of childhood illness indeveloping countries Rationale for an integrated strategy 1999 UNICEF  [Google Scholar]

[3]Ramachandran P, Gopalan HS, Undernutrition & Risk of Infection In Preschool Children Indian Journal of Medical Research 2009 130:579-83.  [Google Scholar]

[4]International Institute For Population Sciences (IIPS) And Macro International. 2007. National Family Health Survey (NFHS-3), 2005-06: India: Vol 1. Mumbai: IIPS; 2007 (http://www.nfhsindia.Org)  [Google Scholar]

[5]WHO. WHO Child Growth Standards (2006) Length/Height For Age,Weight For Age,Weight For Length,Weight For Height And Body Mass Index For Age  [Google Scholar]

[6]Patnaik L, Pattnaik S, Kumar V, Sahu T, Morbidity Pattern Among Under 5 Children In An Urban Slum Area Of Bhubaneswar City, Odisha Indian Journal of Maternal And Child Health 2012 48:1-7.  [Google Scholar]

[7]Kapil U, Nagard D, Gobindi G, Diarrhea Amongst Under Three Children In Rural Haryana Indian Journal of Public Health 1994 28:62-64.  [Google Scholar]

[8]Grover V, Chhabra P, Mallik S, Kannan A, Pattern Of Morbidity AndMortality Amongst Under Fives In An Urban Resettlement Colony Of East Delhi Indian Journal of Preventive And Social Medicine 2004 35:23-26.  [Google Scholar]

[9]Panda P, Benjamin Ai, Zachariah P, Health Status Of Under Fives In A Ludhiana Slum Health And Population - Perspectives And Issues 1993 16:133-41.  [Google Scholar]

[10]Biswas T, Mandal PK, Biswas S, Assessment of Health, Nutrition And Immunisation status amongst Under five Children In Migratory Brick Kiln Population Of Periurban Kolkata, India Sudanese Journal of Public Health 2011 6:7-13.  [Google Scholar]

[11]Elizabeth Am, Raj S. Impact of Biosocial Factors On Morbidity Among Children Aged Under-5 in Orissa.Available at www.Iassh.Org/Web_Abs/68.PdfJu  [Google Scholar]

[12]Shah SM, Yousafzai M, Nurudin B, Lakhani, Rashid A. Chotani, et al. Prevalence and correlates of diarrhea Indian Journal of Pediatrics 2003 70:207-11.  [Google Scholar]

[13]Banerjee B, Hazra S, Bandyopadhyay D, Diarrhea Management Among Under Fives. Brief Reports Indian Pediatrics 2004 41:255-60.  [Google Scholar]

[14]Gulati PV, An Epidemiological Study Of Morbidity Pattern Indian Pediatrics 1977 16:93-97.  [Google Scholar]

[15]Muhe L, Bypass P, Freij L, Sandstrom A, Wall S, A One Year Community Study Of Under Fives in Rural Ethiopia. Patterns Of Morbidity And Public Health Risk Factors Indian Journal of Public Health 1995 109:99-109.N41.  [Google Scholar]

[16]Gupta KB, Walia BNS, A Longitudinal Study Of Morbidity In Children In A Rural Area Of Punjab Indian Journal of Pediatrics 1980 47:297-301.  [Google Scholar]

[17]Gladstone BP, Das AR, Rehman AM, Jaffar S, Estes MK, Muliyil J, Burden of Illness in the First 3 Years of Life in an Indian Slum Journal of Tropical Pediatrics 2010 56:221-26.  [Google Scholar]

[18]Goswami M, Kedia G, Socio-Demographic And Morbidity Profile Of Slum Area In Ahmedabad National Journal Of Community Medicine 2010 1(2):106-10.  [Google Scholar]

[19]Marimuthu P, Meitei MH, Sharma B, General Morbidity Prevalence In The Delhi Slums Indian Journal of Community Medicine 2009 34:338-42.  [Google Scholar]

[20]Sachdeva S, Amir A, Alam S, Khan Z, Ansari MA, Khalique N, Nutritional status of infants and toddlers in rural and urban areas of Aligarh Current Pediatric Research 2010 14:95-100.  [Google Scholar]

[21]Baranwal K, Gupta VM, Mishra RN, Profile of morbidity & their effect on nutritional status of under five children, in urban-slum community Indian Journal of Preventive and Social Medicine 2011 42:123-26.  [Google Scholar]

[22]Swain Basantha K, Mishra S, Immunization Coverage Among Migrant Tribal Children In Slums of Orissa Indian Pediatrics 2006 43:10-1.  [Google Scholar]

[23]Abrol A, Galhotra A, Agarwal N, Bala A, Goel NK, Immunization status in a slum in Chandigarh (U.T) India: A Perspective To Enhance The Service The Internet Journal of Health 2009 8:15-21.  [Google Scholar]

[24]Yadav S, Mangal S, Padhiyar N, Mehta JP, Yadav BS, Evaluation of Immunization Coverage In Urban Slums of Jamnagar City Indian Journal of Community Medicine 2006 31:300-01.  [Google Scholar]

[25]Pore PD, Ghattargi CH, Rayate MV, Study of Risk Factors of Acute Respiratory Infection In Under fives In Solapur National Journal of Community Medicine 2010 1:64-67.  [Google Scholar]

[26]Bhakave D, Epidemiological Study ofAcute Respiratory Infections in Under Six Childrenin Urban ICDS Block A Dissertation for M.D. (P S.M.) 1991   [Google Scholar]

[27]Shah N, Ramanjutty V. Risk factors forsevere pneumonia in children in South Kerala, ahospital based case control study Journal of Tropical Pediatrics 1994 40:201-26.  [Google Scholar]