Congenital malformations remain a common cause of perinatal deaths accounting for 10-15% in developing countries like India.[1] and still remain one of the least focused areas of disease surveillance in India compared with communicable and some chronic disease. Unlike the situations in developed countries, where congenital malformations are leading cause of infant mortality, in India low birth weight, prematurity, sepsis and infections are still the leading causes. Perhaps for this reason not much attention has been paid to the problem of congenital malformations in India [2]. Antenatal sonography developed in recent years, however it continues to lag behind a complete fetal autopsy in accurately diagnosing the cause of fetal death [3]. Only few studies have comparatively examined prenatal ultrasound findings & postnatal autopsy results.
Materials and Methods
The present study comprises 100 consecutive perinatal autopsies conducted after obtaining the approval from the of the Institutional Ethics Committee. In the present study all fetuses with gestational age 20 weeks to 7 completed days after delivery and birth weight greater than 350 g were included while all autolysed foetuses, fetus with gestational age less than 20 weeks and more than 7 days of life, birth weight less than 350 g were excluded.
Consent for autopsy was obtained from either of the parent after explaining the need. Each fetus was examined according to predetermined protocol which included ultrasound diagnosis, photograph, external and internal examination. The autopsy protocol included the removal of thoracic, cervical, abdominal and pelvic organs en block and subsequently dissected into organ blocks [4]. The placenta, fetal membranes and umbilical cord were studied in all the cases. Histological sections were taken from lung, liver, kidney, thymus, brain, placenta and umbilical cord.
In cases where the antenatal ultrasonography diagnosis was available, were compared with the postnatal autopsy findings.
Results
Out of 100 perinatal autopsies, 44 cases were congenital anomalies which included 25 females, 17 males, one case of female pseudohermaphroditism (preesently called as 46 XX Disorders of Sex Development) [5] and one case in which sex could not be identified. Among the 44 cases ,16 were therapeutic terminations, 12 were still births, 8 cases of Intrauterine Deaths and 8 were live born. The most common timing of therapeutic termination encountered in this study was 20 – 24 weeks.
Each case was classified on the basis of gestational age and birth weight. Congenital malformations were common between 35-39 wks & birth weight range 350- 1000g [Table/Fig-1 & 2].
The most common congenital anomalies included Central Nervous System defects, anencephaly being commonest among them. followed by renal anomalies. Multiple congenital anomalies were observed in 7 cases. One case each of Prune Belly syndrome. Meckel Gruber syndrome, Thanatophoric Dysplasia Type 1, Sirenomelia and OEIS (Omphalocele- Exstrophy-Imperforate anus-Spinal defects) complex was seen. 3 cases of diaphragmatic hernia & 2 cases of congenital Atrial Septal Defect were noted. Also encountered were 2 cases of congenital cystic adenomatoid malformation of lungs and 1 case of infantile hemangioendothelioma liver [Table/Fig-3].
Gestational age distribution of congenital anomalies
Gestational age | Number of cases | Percentage (%) |
---|
20- 24 wks | 11 | 25 |
25-29 wks | 11 | 25 |
30-34 wks | 07 | 15.90 |
35-39wks | 13 | 29.54 |
1-7 days | 02 | 4.54 |
Total | 44 | 100 |
Birth weight distribution of congenital anomalies
Birth weight (g) | Total cases | Percentage (%) |
---|
350-1000 | 19 | 43.18 |
1001-2000 | 12 | 27.27 |
2001-3000 | 10 | 22.72 |
3001-4000 | 03 | 6.81 |
Total | 44 | 100 |
One case of Arnold Chiari malformation was encountered in which lower medulla, vermis and cerebellum were herniating through foramen magnum into the upper cervical canal with congenital hydrocephalus. This was of type 2 Chiari malformation which is the commonest of all four types [6].
The Prune Belly syndrome comprised of wrinkled abdomen, absent anterior abdominal wall muscles, empty scrotal sac, rudimentary penis and imperforate anus. Left kidney showed multiple cysts, and microscopy revealed multicystic renal dysplasia. Section from cystic mass at the inferior aspect of bladder showed features of primitive uterine endometrium, also seen were clusters of cells with vacuolated cytoplasm, large vesicular nucleus, prominent nucleoli suggestive of primordial ovarian follicles, favouring the diagnosis of female pseudohermaphrodatism (presently called as 46 XX DSD that is Disorders of Sexual Development as recommended by Consensus Statement in 2006) [5]. In Meckel Gruber syndrome, the classical triad was present which included posterior encephalocele , also diagnosed on ultrasonography, upper limb polydactyly and diffuse cystic dysplasia along with pulmonary hypoplasia, ductal plate malformation liver and penile agenesis. Thanatophoric Dysplasia type 1, fetus had large head with frontal bossing, narrow thorax, depressed nasal bridge, generalized edema, rhizhomalic shortening of lower limbs [Table/Fig-4] and section from femur growth plate reveals marked retardation of growth zone, fibrous band noted at the periphery of the physeal growth plate, with disordered and hypertrophic chondrocytes. The case of Mermaid syndrome demonstrated imperforate anus, single umbilical artery and bilateral renal agenesis [Table/Fig-5] with X ray showing single lower limb with only 2 bones. OEIS complex was diagnosed on the findings of omphalocele, exstrophy of the cloaca, imperforate anus, and spinal defects which included meningomyelocele [Table/Fig-6].
Prenatal ultrasound finding were available in 39 cases. Autopsy diagnosis confirmed the prenatal ultrasound diagnosis in 35 cases and in 13 cases additional findings were observed. In 4 cases there was discordance with prenatal ultrasound diagnosis. [Table/Fig-7].
System wise distribution of congenital anomalies
Congenital anomalies | Associated anomalies | Number of cases ( n=44) |
---|
1) CNS Defects | | 15 (34.09%) |
a) Meningocele | Rachischisis | 2 |
b) Anencephaly | | 7 |
c) Anencephaly with meningocele | | 1 |
d) Meningomyelocele | | 1 |
e) Microcephaly and encephalocele | | 1 |
f) Arnold chiari malformation | Congenital Hydrocephalus | 1 |
g) Absent corpus callosum | | 1 |
h) Congenital Hydrocephalus | Spina bifida | 1 |
2) Renal Defects | | 9 (20.45%) |
a) Renal agenesis | | |
- Unilateral | Imperforate anus | 1 |
- Bilateral | Imperforate anus, ambiguous genitilia, SUA* | 1 |
b) Polycystic kidney disease | | |
- Unilateral | Imperforate anus, polydactyly, CTEV †, SUA* | 1 |
- Bilateral | Liver plate malformation, polydactyly | 2 |
c) Wilms tumor | DORV‡ | 1 |
d) Obstructive uropathy (PUV) | -ASD §(secundum), CTEV† -Hydronephrosis, hydroureter | 1 |
e) Horse shoe kidney | Hydrops fetalis | 1 |
3) Multiple Congenital Anomalies | 1) Cleft lip, depressed nasal bridge, low set ears, polydactyly, syndactyly, MS†† | 7(15.91%) |
| 2) Anencephaly with multicystic renal dysplasia | |
| 3) Anencephaly, diaphragmatic hernia & facial deformities | |
| 4) Low set ears & polydactyly | |
| 5) Hydrocephalus with low set ears & cleft lip | |
| 6) Sacrococcygeal teratoma with SUA* | |
| 7) HMD ¶ with SUA * & thoracolumbar scoliosis | |
4) Syndromes | | 5 (11.36) |
a) Prune Belly syndrome | | 1 |
b) Meckel Gruber syndrome | | 1 |
c) Sirenomelia/Mermaid syndrome | | 1 |
d) Thanatophoric dysplasia Type 1 | | 1 |
e) OEIS** | | 1 |
5) Diaphragmatic Hernia | Shortened cervical spine(C1-5 fusion) | 3 (6.82%) |
6) Cardiac Defects | | 2 (4.54%) |
a) ASD (Secondum) | Choanal atresia | 1 |
b) ASD With MS†† | Hypoplastic left heart syndrome | 1 |
7) Respiratory | Cystic adenomatoid malformation of lung | 2 (4.54%) |
8) Infantile Hemangioendothelioma | | 1(2.27%) |
Single umbilical artery
Congenital Talipes Equino Varus
Double Outlet Right Ventricle
Atrial Septal Defect
Hyaline Membrane Disease
Omphalocele- Exstrophy-Imperforate anus-Spinal defects
Mitral Stenosis
Thanatophoric Dysplasia Type 1- large head with frontal bossing, narrow thorax, depressed nasal bridge, generalized edema, shortening of lower limbs

Mermaid syndrome � Fetus showing flexed single lower extremity, shield chest and lack of external genitilia

Fetus with omphalocele and club foot in a case of OEIS complex

A case of multiple malformations including cleft lip, depressed nasal bridge, low set ears, polydactyly and syndactyly

Discussion
Fetal autopsy significantly contributes to the diagnosis of Intrauterine fetal death and congenital anomalies are a major cause of perinatal death [3]. In the present study of 100 perinatal autopsies, 44 cases of congenital anomalies were encountered with M:F ratio of 1:1.5. The most common mode of death was therapeutic termination of pregnancy (36.36%) and CNS malformations were most common indication for the same. The gestational age of most of the fetuses with congenital anomalies ranged from 35-39 wks & birth weight range 350-1000g. The most common defects were of Central Nervous System, seen in 15 cases (34.09) which correlates with the study of Kaiser et al., [7] and Tomatir et al., [9] [Table/Fig-8]. The most common defect was Anencephaly with 11 cases (25%), which was accurately diagnosed with Ultrasonography.
The next common anomalies were of Renal system accounting for 9 cases ( 20.45%) which included renal agenesis, polycystic kidney disease, Wilms tumor, obstructive uropathy and horseshoe kidney which was incidently observed in a case of Hydrops Fetalis. The finding is also supported by study conducted by Sankar & Phadke where urinary tract malformations constituted the second most common group of anomalies [1].
There were 7 cases(15.91%) of multiple malformations [Table/Fig-9] not fitting into any specific diagnosis, 5 cases (11.36%) of syndromes diagnosed as Prune Belly syndrome, Meckel Gruber syndrome, Thanatophoric Dysplasia Type 1, Mermaid syndrome or Sirenomelia and OEIS complex, 3 cases (6.82%) of diaphragmatic hernia, 2 cases (4.54%) of congenital heart defects and 2 cases (4.54%) of congenital cystic adenomatoid malformations lung. A case of Infantile hemangioendothelioma liver [Table/Fig-10] was encountered.
The Prune Belly syndrome encountered in this study was associated with female pseudohermaphrodatism (46 XX DSD) [5] which is extremely rare with only 4 reported cases so far [10]. Meckel Gruber syndrome, a lethal rare autosomal recessive disorder, characterized by an occipital encephalocele, cystic dysplastic kidneys and polydactyly (constituting classical triad). Associated features that can be present are ductal plate malformation liver, ambiguous genitilia and hypoplastic lungs which were all seen in this case. Over 200 cases has been reported so far [11].
Thanatophoric dysplasia is one of the most common and severe form of dwarfism. It is always lethal; most of them die within a few hours after birth [12]. The case seen in the present study was diagnosed to be of type 1.
Sirenomelia represents a severe form of caudal regression and is comprised of Potter’s facies, single umbilical artery, bilateral renal agenesis, absent bladder and fused lower limb [13] and generallty classified as Simpus Apus, Simpus Unipus and Simpus Dipus (mermaid). The present case was of Simpus Apus type. Over 300 cases have been reported so far of which 8 cases are reported from India [14].
Comparison of USG findings with Autopsy Diagnosis
USG Findings | No. of Cases = 39 | (%) |
---|
Confirmed | 35 | 79.54 |
No Change in Diagnosis | 22 | 50 |
Added to Diagnosis | 13 | 29.54 |
Change In Diagnosis | 04 | 9.09 |
USG Diagnosis | Autopsy Diagnosis | | |
1. Cystic Hygroma | Thanatophoric Dysplasia type 1 | | |
2. Fetal microcephaly with hydronephrosis | B/L PCKD with microcepaly and occipital meningocele | | |
3. Polyhydroamnios (AFI 15*) | Diaphragmatic hernia posterolateral type | | |
4. Hydrops fetalis | Hypoplastic lung with Meningocele | | |
Comparitive Analysis of Central Nervous Anomalies
S No. | Authors | Year | Number/Total | Percentage (%) |
---|
1. | Kaiser et al [7] | 2000 | 45/121 | 37 |
---|
2. | Sankar and Phadke [1] | 2006 | 60/81 | 74.2 |
3. | Grover N et al [8] | 2007 | 72/180 | 40 |
4. | Tomatir et al [9] | 2009 | 57/183 | 31.1 |
5. | Present study | 2012 | 15/44 | 34.09 |
OEIS complex, involving omphalocele, exstrophy of the bladder, imperforate anus, and spinal abnormalities/ myelomeningocele, is a rare association with incidence of 1 in 200 000 to 1 in 250 000 births. The present case had ambiguous genitilia and club foot which are described as associated features [15].
In the present study, autopsy diagnosis confirmed Ultrasound findings in 35 cases (79.54%), among these in 13 cases(29.54%) it provided additional information while primary diagnosis was changed in 4 cases(9.09%). The findings in this study were similar to those of Sankar and Phadke [1] & Yeo et al., [17] [Table/Fig-11].
Infantile Hemangioendothelioma with immature cord of hepatic cells divided vascular interconnecting channels, cavernous at places lined by plump endothelial cells. (H & E , 400 X)

Conclusion
Even though the prenatal ultrasonogram reasonably predicts the malformations, fetal autopsy is essential to look for additional malformations [1]. In this study fetal autopsy helped in confirming the diagnosis of congenital malformations by antenatal ultrasound findings and identified additional findings in approximately one third of the cases.
This study confirms the utility of fetal autopsy in identifying the cause of fetal loss which will help in genetic counselling of the couple.
Comparitive study of Fetal Autopsy and Ultrasonography
S No. | Authors | Year | Confirmed USG findings | Changed primary diagnosis |
---|
No change in diagnosis | Added to diagnosis |
---|
1. | Pahi, Phadke et al., [16] | 1998 | 30/61 (49.18%) | 10/61 (16.39%) | 21/61 (34.4%) |
2. | Yeo et al., [17] | 2002 | 27/88 (30.68%) | 30/88 (34.09%) | 31/88 (35.22%)) |
3. | Sankar & Phadke [1] | 2006 | 55/134 (41.04%) | 77/134 (57.46%) | 2/134 (1.49%) |
4. | Present study | 2012 | 22/35 (50%) | 13/35 (29.54%) | 4/35 (9.09%) |