JCDR - Register at Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research
Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research, ISSN - 0973 - 709X
Nursing Section DOI : 10.7860/JCDR/2021/48465.15024
Year : 2021 | Month : Jun | Volume : 15 | Issue : 06 Full Version Page : LC12 - LC14

Awareness and Perspective of Nursing Tutee on Proof Relied Enactment at Selected Nursing Colleges of Central Gujarat, India

Arpan Pandya1

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Nursing, Manikaka Topawala Institute of Nursing, Charotar University of Science and Technology, Anand, Gujarat, India.


NAME, ADDRESS, E-MAIL ID OF THE CORRESPONDING AUTHOR: Mr. Arpan Pandya, Assistant Professor, Department of Nursing, Manikaka Topawala Institute of Nursing, A Constituent of Charotar University of Science and Technology, Charusat Changa Accredited Grade a by NAAC Accredited Grade a by KCGTaPetlad Dist Anand, Gujarat, India.
E-mail: arpanpandya.nur@charusat.ac.in
Abstract

Introduction

Nursing tutee are traditionally following the set benchmarks of nursing care. Several researchers have observed a wide gap between present awareness and perspective of nursing tutee in relation to recent healthcare developmental proofs and their day-to-day nursing activity. In the present study researcher has made an attempt to assess the Proof Relied Enactment (PRE) skills to find out their status.

Aim

To assess the possessed awareness and perspective of final year Bachelor of Science (BSc) Nursing tutee regarding PRE.

Materials and Methods

This descriptive survey was conducted among the fourth year BSc Nursing students in selected Nursing colleges of central Gujarat, India from January 2020 to December 2020. Purposive sampling technique was used and a sample of 120 students was included in the study. Descriptive and inferential statistics including mean, Chi-square and Karl Pearson coefficient of correlation was used to analyse the results.

Results

The study showed that learning of fundamentals of PRE has significant correlation with utilisation status of PRE whereas rest of variables displayed negative correlation. The mean awareness score was 20.1 and SD was 2.91, whereas mean score for use of evidence resources was 28.24 and SD was 2.95, mean score for utilisation status for PRE was 6.15 whereas SD was 1.47, mean perspective score was 107.94 and SD was 10.93. None of the demographic showed statistically significant association with perspectives of tutee on PRE. There was positive correlation between awareness and perspective of nursing tutee on PRE.

Conclusion

Nursing tutee who learned PRE in their curriculum consciously improved their PRE skills and were more productive during study.

Keywords

Introduction

The PRE also known as Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) is a process of finding relevant empirical research evidence-based references ranked on evidence hierarchy to take appropriate clinical decision. The PRE is judicial use of available empirical research evidences to formulate appropriate clinical decision. The PRE is fenced by various factors viz., lack of skills and knowledge of concept, misinterpretation and pessimism towards PRE, lack of confidence that PRE will be a finer solution of problems, puzzled pool of available information, candidature incompetence along with time and resource constraints, limited availability of PRE guides, incorporation of clients for application of ideas, peer weight to proceed with hones that soaks in tradition etc. [1]. The study was intended to explore the status of nursing student regarding PRE and its utilisation skills in day to day nursing care provided by them. Researcher was willing to find out the awareness status of tutee regarding these concepts and the extent of skills possessed by them in provision of PRE care.

The aim of study was to test the understanding and perspective of the final year BSc nursing tutee related to PRE. The study also tried to find any association of demographic variables with level of awareness, perspective and correlation of awareness and perspective scores. This study had measured student’s awareness and perspective as well as to sensitise them regarding the topic, which may act as inspiration to enrich their PRE concepts and clinical application of it.

Materials and Methods

A descriptive survey was designed among final year BSc Nursing tutee at various nursing colleges of central Gujarat, India from January 2020 to December 2020. Ethical clearance along with permission to conduct the study was obtained from Institutional Ethical Committee (IEC) letter no.-CHA/ADMIN/NUR/19/04/156.

Inclusion criteria: Tutee studying in fourth year BSc Nursing who were available at the time of data collection and were willing to participate in study by providing their informed consent for data collection were included in the study.

Exclusion criteria: Tutee who had not come across term PRE in their nursing studies were excluded from the study.

Sample size calculation: A purposive sampling technique was used to select the sample. Power estimation was done to find approximate sample size using literature review and formula as advised by statistician (4pq/n2). The reason was relying in curriculum of final year BSc nursing tutee who study the concept partially as a part of their final year BSc (N) curriculum and it was an assumption of researcher that these tutees will have some awareness about the concept. A total 120 tutee from four nursing institutions participated in study.

Study Instruments

Researcher had previous experience of teaching PRE to nursing tutee. Based on skills acquired researcher explored many text books and University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics [2], was contacted for their Dissemination of Nursing Knowledge: Tips and Resources and EBP in Action tools. Researcher had formally acquired permission from them to utilise the said tool for study [3]. Researcher procured information from various resources and generated self-developed tool for study, which was then sent for validation and reliability of research tool was established after a pilot study. The reliability score of study was r=0.8. After receiving detailed validation of tool, researcher finally designed research tool used for present study. The study tool was broadly framed under following headings:

A) Demographic variables including level of students, gender, learned fundamentals of PRE in nursing curriculum, any previous training specifically regarding EBP.

B) Awareness regarding PRE (26 items).

C) Use of evidence resources in nursing {8 items (5-point rating scale)}.

D) Utilisation skills status about PRE application (11 items).

E) Perspective of tutee on PRE (31 items).

The study tool was made in English language. The mean awareness scores were calculated by calculating mean of scored under awareness scores response section.

Statistical Analysis

Inferential and descriptive analysis of results was done to analyse study results. Chi-square test was applied to find association of awareness and perspective with demographic characteristics of tutee. Data analysis was done under guidance of statistician and presented as required.

Results

Among 120 participants, 15 (12.5%) were male and 105 (87.5%) were female, 99 (82.5%) of them had learned fundamentals of PRE and 21 (17.5%) were not able to recall it, 40 (33.33%) had previous training of PRE and 80 (66.67%) had not undergone any previous training of PRE.

The mean awareness score was 20.1 and SD was 2.911. The Chi-square value for gender was 0.126, learned fundamentals of evidence was 0.009 and any previous training specifically regarding PRE was 0.364. Majority of the variable had significant association with level of awareness except learned fundamentals of evidences (p= 0.000084).

[Table/Fig-1] depicts the awareness scores of study participants regarding various segments of tool. Out of 120 participants, 76.67% have good whereas 23.33% had average awareness of PRE, 89.17% are good where as 10.83% have average use of evidence resources in nursing, 2.5% (3) have good, 90% (108) had average and and 7.5% (9) have poor scores regarding utilisation of PRE.

Awareness scores of participants.

Awareness scores on PREGoodAveragePoorN=120
Criteria
1Awareness regarding PRE922800Good (19-26)Average (10-18)Poor (0-9)
2Use of proof resources in nursing1071300Good (27-40)Average (14-26)Poor (0-13)
3Utilisation skills status about PRE application0310809Good (9 -11)Average (5-8)Poor (0-4)

The mean score for use of evidence resources was 28.24 and SD was 2.95 and was found non significant in association with demographic variables. None of the variables showed statistically significant association with perspectives of tutee on PRE [Table/Fig-2]. A statistically weak positive correlation (p=0.046) was found between awareness and perspective score [Table/Fig-3].

Perspective scores of participants.

Perspective scoresTotalChi-squareDFp-value
Favourable (94-155)Unfavourable (31-93)
GenderFemale9961050.02210.883
Male14115
Learned fundamentals of proof relied enactment in nursing curriculumDo not remember173203.67110.055
Yes964100
Any previous training specifically regarding proof relied enactmentNo746801.21410.271
Yes39140

Chi-square test, p<0.05 statistically significant


Correlations of awareness and perspective score.

VariablesAwareness scorePerspective
Pearson correlation10.046
Sig. (2-tailed)-0.617
Total N120120

The mean score for utilisation status for PRE was 6.15 whereas SD was 1.47, mean perspective score was 107.94 and SD was 10.93. PRE is emerging as one of the fastest growing field in health care. Results of study revealed following outcome.

Discussion

Research based proofed resources are serving as backbone of today’s healthcare services. It is the integration of clinical skill and the available research evidence to make a decision for patient care [4]. As it was seen in present study that there was a positive weak correlation between awareness and perspective scores regarding evidence relying methods among aspirants of nursing. A pool of nursing tutee expressed non certainty in any component of study, hence critical relationship between awareness and perspective scores were found. For present study EBP in Action tools was adopted and enriched with self-developed questionnaire to form final research tool.

As per results analysis it is observed that Cochrane and high-level evidences are referred occasionally or at minimal instance which indicates there is a lack of evidence reference priority skills among samples and lower level of resources as per evidence hierarchy is preferred more due to it’s easy accessibility. It is observed as many of them are aware about PRE but do not show an approach to apply in their practice. Present study recommends to include PRE in academic curriculum as an integral part in all nursing education courses.

Belowska J et al., conducted a study to analyse the knowledge and attitude of nursing tutee towards evidence based medicine and evidence based nursing Practice at Medical University of Warsaw and concluded that nursing education programme should include evidence-based medicine and nursing practice in curriculum to facilitate their knowledge and let them reap the benefits of using latest research proofs in exercising nursing. They also found that knowledge level of participants was strongly insufficient. Researcher recommended that improving PRE skills and literacy is essential to uplift practice [5].

Azmoude E et al., conducted a study to reveal knowledge, practice and self-efficiency in EBP at Eastern Iran. The study results demonstrated consistency with present study results and concluded that there is a need for improvement in the self-efficacy, practice and knowledge of EBP [6].

Zhou F et al., conducted a multiple institutional cross-sectional survey in China to explore nurse’s knowledge, attitude and practice on EBP. Study results had shown positive response of participants which comprised of positive attitude towards PRE, which was in coherence with present study results indicating weak but positive correlation among awareness and perspectives of tutees [7].

Limitation(s)

The present study was limited to students of final year BSc (N) studying at nursing colleges of central Gujarat, India. The study was limited to student’s assessable during data collection via online mode.

Conclusion(s)

The study results concluded that samples have scope for improvement of PRE perception awareness for better nursing care. It is observed that some aspects like utilisation skills status about PRE application are explicitly lacking and needs to be improved by the means of curriculum strengthening and frequent refresher training. Based on above discussion researcher believes that PRE should be adopted in nursing curriculum for ensuring nourishment of upcoming nurses with these skills since the inception of their training, tutees must be sensitised for concepts of PRE and it’s clinical application, use of PRE in nursing care planning, education and decision making should be encouraged and prescribed by authorities to inculcate culture of PRE in students. Present study also advocates to promote institutional skill attainment programmes for promoting PRE.

A further study can be done among Undergraduate (UG) or Postgraduate (PG) nursing students, faculties teaching at various nursing students or among the nurse’s working at health care facilities. These studies can be done for assessment of PRE practice among nurse’s in clinical setting as base research to develop PRE operational SOP’s and guidelines for clinical practice.

Chi-square test, p<0.05 statistically significant

References

[1]Melnyk BM, Fineout-Overholt E, “Evidence-based practice in nursing & healthcare: A guide to best Practice”, 2nd Edi “Barriers of Evidence based practice” Lippincott and Williams and WilkinsChapter 17, page no. 41)  [Google Scholar]

[2]Cullen L, Hanrahan K, Farrington M, DeBerg J, Tucker S, Kleiber C. (2018). Evidence-based practice in action: Comprehensive strategies, tools, and tips from the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics. Indianapolis, IN: Sigma Theta Tau International  [Google Scholar]

[3]Hanrahan K, Marlow KL, Aldrich C, Hiatt, AM (2010). Dissemination of nursing knowledge: Tips and reis. University of Iowa College of Nursing. pp. 1-21  [Google Scholar]

[4]Masic I, Miokovic M, Muhamedagic B, Evidence based medicine- New approaches and challenges Acta Informatica Medica 2008 16(4):21910.5455/aim.2008.16.219-22524109156  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[5]Belowska J, Panczyk M, Zarzeka A, Gotlib J, Knowledge and attitudes of nursing students towards evidence-based medicine and evidence-based nursing practice Zdrow Publiczne 2015 125(4):201-04.10.1515/pjph-2015-0055  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]

[6]Azmoude E, Farkhondeh F, Ahour M, Kabirian M, Knowledge, practice and self-efficacy in evidence-based practice among midwives in east Iran Sultan Qaboos Univ Med J 2017 17(1):e66-73.10.18295/squmj.2016.17.01.01228417031  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[7]Zhou F, Hao Y, Guo H, Liu H, Attitude, knowledge, and practice on evidence-based nursing among registered nurses in traditional Chinese medicine hospitals: A multiple center cross-sectional survey in China Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2016 2016:547808610.1155/2016/547808627528882  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]