JCDR - Register at Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research
Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research, ISSN - 0973 - 709X
Others Section DOI : 10.7860/JCDR/2021/47276.14935
Year : 2021 | Month : May | Volume : 15 | Issue : 05 Full Version Page : BC27 - BC30

Student Perception Regarding the Utility of Information Technology as a Facilitator of Learning in Medical Education

Vatsala Khurana1, Rashmi Verma2, Binita Goswami3, Vikas Malhotra4

1 Postgraduate Student, Department of Biochemistry, Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi, India.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Biochemistry, Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi, India.
3 Professor, Department of Biochemistry, Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi, India.
4 Professor, Department of Ear, Nose and Throat and Incharge (Information Technology), Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi, India.


NAME, ADDRESS, E-MAIL ID OF THE CORRESPONDING AUTHOR: Dr. Vatsala Khurana, Department of Biochemistry, Maulana Azad Medical College, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg, New Delhi-110002, India.
E-mail: vats.khurana@gmail.com
Abstract

Introduction

Information Technology (IT) has influenced all fields including healthcare and Medical Education (ME). The present generation of students have grown up in an IT enriched atmosphere and are comfortable with most IT tools and gadgets.

Aim

To understand the perception of first year MBBS students regarding role of IT in ME.

Materials and Methods

A cross-divtional, questionnaire based study was carried out on 250 first year MBBS students from August 1st, 2019 to August 31st, 2019 over a period of one month. A questionnaire containing three divtions was administered to the students before the starting of IT module in foundation year. The responses to the items of the questionnaire were assessed on the basis of the student responses on the likert scale.

Results

The study revealed that students acknowledged the utility of IT for academic purposes and were primed for its inclusion as an essential component of the medical curriculum. The students conceded to browsing internet on their computers and smartphones for social media handles. However, when it came to teaching methods, students were not comfortable with the idea of replacing traditional teaching methods with e-learning. Also, students were more comfortable in reading hard copies instead of e-books.

Conclusion

It was concluded that there is a need to amalgamate the traditional teaching methods with the innovative e-learning platforms in such a way that they become mutually inclusive and facilitate the learning process. Also, ME practices need to be continuously re-evaluated to make the educational process more effective for learners, teachers and for the society in general.

Keywords

Introduction

The IT is defined as the technology involving the development, maintenance, and use of computer systems, software, and networks for the processing and distribution of data [1]. The IT has become indispensable for efficient functioning of all fields and healthcare sector is no different. The present generation of students have grown up in an IT enriched atmosphere and hence, comfortable with most forms of IT tools and gadgets. The degree of exposure and ease with the gadgets varies between the students hailing from metropolitan cities and those from small towns. Advances in information and networking technology have encouraged policy makers to reframe learning objectives and learning methods in order to integrate technological processes for educational innovations. The Medical Council of India (MCI) took cognisance of the increasing dependence of the generation on IT and its potential role in transforming healthcare. Hence, a module on IT has now been made mandatory in the foundation course of newly implemented Competency Based Medical Education (CBME) in Indian medical colleges. Therefore, this study was conducted to gauge the basic level of IT understanding of the new MBBS entrants as well as understand their perception regarding the application of IT in education tools and assess their level of comfort with usage of IT tools.

Materials and Methods

A cross-sectional, questionnaire based study was carried out on 250 first year MBBS students from August 1st, 2019 to August 31st, 2019. Ethical approval was not required for this project as per the Institutional Ethics Committee as this was an anonymous questionnaire-based study based on ME. The study was conducted at Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi, India. A total of 250 first year MBBS students were given the questionnaire.

Questionnaire

The self-administered questionnaire containing three sections was administered to the students before the commencement of the IT module made mandatory in the foundation course of newly implemented CBME. The first section included questions regarding the basic understanding and usage of IT tools by the students during their pre MBBS days; the second section included statements regarding the students’ perception about the usage of IT during imparting ME in the medical college whereas the last section attempted to gauge the student comprehension of terms such as e-learning, e-portfolios etc., which have now become integral part of ME. The questionnaire was validated by three senior faculty members of the institute.

The responses to the items of the questionnaire were assessed on the basis of the student responses on the likert scale for section 2 and 3. Section 1 comprised of qualitative data which was analysed in accordance with principle of qualitative data handling.

Statistical Analysis

The data was analysed using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 20.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, USA).

Results

A total of 198 students filled the questionnaire. Sixty three percent of students were male and 35% females, 4 students (2%) didn’t fill the gender. Seventy eight percent of the students had computer rest of the students were using a smartphone. Maximum number of students had acquired computer skills through classes held in school or coaching centre. Majority of students felt that IT had an important role in healthcare and that IT training should be an essential part of curriculum. However, when it came to teaching methods, students were not comfortable with the idea of replacing traditional teaching with e-learning and felt that resources on the internet were not a good replacement for faculty. Also, students chose reading hard copies over e-books but found online discussion boards and forums to be of much use for learning. Most of the students agreed to the fact that internet provides rapid access to information and agreed upon use of e-mails for communication instead of offline circulars. Majority of students were found to be proficient in creating and editing word file and powerpoint presentation but not excel spreadsheets [Table/Fig-1]. Students were also asked to evaluate their skill levels in various computer applications. Students were found to be confident in only few applications like word processing, powerpoint presentations, worldwide web and social media [Table/Fig-2]. However, they were not aware about terms such as hospital information system, podcasting, e-portfolios and e-learning which is understandable due to lack of exposure to complete e-learning platforms at schools.

Student responses on the likert scale on questions regarding utility of IT in Medical Education (ME).

S. No.Questions01234BlankMedianMean
1IT has important role in healthcare0 (0)1 (0.5)9 (4.6)70 (35.7)116 (59.2)243.54
2IT training should be an essential part of curriculum3 (1.52)1 (0.51)35 (17.77)69 (35.03)89 (45.18)133.22
3Internet provides rapid access to information0 (0)1 (1.03)2 (2.06)35 (36.08)159 (60.82)143.79
4I prefer to read e-books than hard copies58 (29.4)67 (34.0)53 (26.9)11 (5.6)8 (4.1)111.21
5E-mails can be used for student communication instead of offline circulars8 (4.1)11 (5.6)53 (26.9)72 (36.5)53 (26.9)132.77
6I use computers only for social networking60 (30.6)69 (35.2)44 (22.4)16 (8.2)7 (3.6)211.19
7I feel teaching should be replaced by e-learning46 (23.5)41 (20.9)57 (29.1)31 (15.8)21 (10.7)221.69
8Having access to computer technology is very important for medical students academic success6 (3.1)8 (4.1)37 (18.9)79 (40.3)66 (33.7)232.97
9Online discussion boards and forums are not useful in student learning59 (29.9)72 (36.5)45 (22.8)14 (7.1)7 (3.6)111.18
10Resources on the internet don’t make a good replacement for faculty2 (1.0)13 (6.6)25 (12.7)78 (39.6)79 (40.1)133.11
11I am well versed with information about computer components12 (6.1)24 (12.2)44 (22.4)58 (29.6)58 (29.6)232.64
12I am fully aware about how to edit, delete, copy, modify a word file15 (7.6)12 (6.1)16 (8.1)50 (25.4)104 (52.8)143.1
13I am fully aware about how to edit, delete, copy, modify worksheets in excel19 (9.6)24 (12.2)49 (24.9)52 (26.4)53 (26.9)132.49
14I am fully aware about how to edit, delete, copy, modify presentations in powerpoint18 (9.2)12 (6.1)21 (10.7)58 (29.6)87 (44.4)232.94

0 signifies least score and 4 highest score; values described as n (%)


Student baseline knowledge regarding the various IT terminologies and technologies used in ME.

S. No.ParameterABCDBLANKA (%)B (%)C (%)D (%)
1Word processing33637324516.731.836.912.1
2Graphic programs12061112460.630.85.61.0
3Spreadsheets8165418340.932.820.74.0
4Powerpoint presentations1954784349.627.339.421.7
5World wide web21367562410.618.237.931.3
6E-mail521987132.510.649.535.9
7Social-media applications1126936445.613.147.032.3
8Chatrooms, forums78454624539.422.723.212.1
9Hospital information system1711523786.47.61.01.5
10Community information system1662331583.811.61.50.5
11Electronic health records1513470676.317.23.50.0
12Electronic medication system1513470676.317.23.50.0
13e-health systems1414550771.222.72.50.0
14Telehealth systems1712010686.410.10.50.0
15Research software1314884766.224.24.02.0
16Webcasting1572444979.312.12.02.0
17Video-conferencing46854516623.242.922.78.1
18Virtual-reality, simulation110551510855.627.87.65.1
19Internet/Radio/Video TV1739775878.619.738.929.3
20e-learning software48526725624.226.333.812.6
21Cell and smartphones718858263.59.142.941.4
22Tablets1741696568.620.734.832.8
23Digital camera27626636713.631.333.318.2
24Educational games33745728616.737.428.814.1
25Artificial intelligence9958268750.029.313.14.0

A-No experience, novice

B-Some experience, Advanced beginner

C-Comfortable user, competent

D-Skilled user, proficient


Discussion

The present day college and university students comprise of a generation who have grown up in a digital environment with IT becoming indispensable for daily living. Children are now proficient with smartphones even before they become verbal. Since social media and IT has become an integral part of lives in such a sweeping manner, it would really be worthwhile to utilise it for imparting education [2]. The field of IT is dynamic and evolving with newer softwares and tools being added to the enormous kitty every day. This gargantuan collection can be used to foster student-faculty interaction and facilitate self-directed learning and understanding through online classrooms, online resources and assessment tools. The IT also provides immense potential for collaborative learning and community outreach. Simulation technology is used for imparting technical skills such as laproscopic procedures, anaesthesia and surgical skills, emergency resuscitation, and management that are otherwise difficult in view of lack of resources [3,4].

Keeping these advantages in mind, e-learning was introduced in curriculum in the western world. Though it was accepted with a lot of enthusiasm by both students and teachers, a number of issues have somehow slowed its full-fledged incorporation in developing countries like India. The need for basic infrastructure such as internet connection, functional computers and computer literacy among both students and teachers in our cash strapped education branch makes it difficult to implement [5]. Moreover, the absence of emotional connects and real presence of the teacher in the virtual world leads to demotivation and isolation among the students. Nonetheless the outreach of IT cannot be neglected and the government is striving to provide infrastructure to impart e-learning to students to keep them at par with their western counterparts.

Taking all this into consideration, a questionnaire was designed to assess the perception of first year MBBS undergraduate students regarding the use of newer forms of technology in teaching methods and what forms of technology they are comfortable with using in their day to day activities. This will benefit in designing e-learning modules for them on the basis of their basic exposure and comfort level.

The present study revealed that students acknowledged the utility of IT for academic purposes and were primed for its inclusion as an essential component of our medical curriculum. The students conceded to browsing internet on their computers and smartphones for social media handles. However, when it came to teaching methods, students were not comfortable with the idea of replacing traditional teaching methods with e-learning. Majority of students were found to be proficient in creating and editing word file and powerpoint presentation but not excel spreadsheets. They also proposed for the digital dissemination of circulars. There are many reasons justifying this for example: easy accessibility, easy sharing, storage for future reference and availability of print outs as and when required [6]. In our study, students did not prefer reading e-books over hard copies. This is in agreement with the general consensus. People in general like reading hard copies [7]. The use of Online Discussion Forum (ODF) has emerged as a common tool and an effective way of engaging students in the learning process [8]. The ODF is an e-learning platform that provides students with privilege to post messages to the discussion threads, interact and receive feedback from other students and instructor, and hence, create a deeper understanding of the subject matter being discussed. In this study, the students found online discussion boards and forums useful for better understanding of the subject. However, students still felt that teachers are still required and e-learning cannot be a replacement for faculty.

Researchers have already tapped the technology savvy approach of medical students and studies have yielded encouraging results. Huang HM et al., reported the positive outlook of the learners towards the use of this form of technology as a teaching method [9]. Similarly the utility of IT in anatomy has been documented by Lim KH et al., [10]. The enhancement of learning outcomes and better participation of students in e-classrooms has been documented by Fonseca N et al., and Gulek JC and Demirtas H, respectively among others [11,12]. The practicality of using smartphones which have now become an absolute necessity in reinforcing comprehension and understanding among medical students has been documented by many researchers such as Valle J et al., Gavali MY et al., among others [13,14].

However, many report contrary results with the advent of IT on the student performance. Lewis TL et al., reported that evidence is not convincing enough regarding the applicability of mobile apps for education [15]. Another study by Malaney GD reported fall in grades owing to excessive time spent over the internet surfing for online resources [16]. Moreover, there is no supervision on their online activities which may be digressing to social media handles rather than academic web-surfing [17].

Limitation(s)

There are however certain limitations to this study. It has a relatively small sample size. Also, this was a point of time study, where the perception of students was assessed just at the beginning of their course based on whatever knowledge of IT they already had. No follow-ups were conducted.

Conclusion(s)

The ME practices need to be continuously re-evaluated to make the educational process more effective for learners, teachers and for the society in general. The usage of IT is increasing in all fields including healthcare and ME. Both students and teachers are exploring new options for teaching-learning activities which are easy to use, interactive and effectively impart knowledge. There is a need to amalgamate the traditional teaching methods with the innovative e-learning platforms in such a way that they become mutually inclusive and facilitate the learning process. The teacher student camaraderie and the human touch need to be kept intact to make our students empathetic towards the society and become community healers instead of repositories of knowledge obtained from multiple search engines. There exists a huge potential for future research as it can be analysed if the perception of students towards IT changed as they moved ahead in their MBBS course and got exposed to newer e-learning techniques and technology to assist them in their learning process.

0 signifies least score and 4 highest score; values described as n (%)A-No experience, noviceB-Some experience, Advanced beginnerC-Comfortable user, competentD-Skilled user, proficient

References

[1]Petimani MS, Adake P, Blackboard versus PowerPoint presentation: Students opinion in medical education Int J Educ Psychol Res 2015 1:289-92.10.4103/2395-2296.163935  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]

[2]Saenger AK, Berkwits M, Carley S, Haymond S, Ennis-O’Connor M, Sherbino J, The Power of social media in medicine and medical education: Opportunities, risks, and rewards Clin Chem 2018 64(9):1284-90.10.1373/clinchem.2018.28822529789353  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[3]de Montbrun SL, Macrae H, Simulation in surgical education Clin Colon Rectal Surg 2012 25(3):156-65.10.1055/s-0032-132255323997671  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[4]Rotem A, Godwin P, Du J, Learning in hospital settings Teach Learn Med 1995 7(4):211-17.10.1080/10401339509539746  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]

[5]Dhir SK, Verma D, Batta M, Mishra D, E-learning in medical education in India Indian Pediatr 2017 54:871-77.10.1007/s13312-017-1152-929120336  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[6]Ward J, Gordon J, Field M, Lehmann H, Communication and information technology in medical education The Lancet 2010 357(9258):792-96.10.1016/S0140-6736(00)04173-8  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]

[7]Handley L, Physical books still outsell e-books- and here’s why, CNBC Available at: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/09/19/physical-books-still-outsell-e-books-and-heres-why.html (Accessed: 17 January 2020)  [Google Scholar]

[8]Balaji MS, Charkrabarti D, Student interactions in online discussion forum: Empirical research from ‘media richness theory’ perspective Journal of Interactive Online Learning 2010 9(1):01-22.Retrieved from: https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ938834  [Google Scholar]

[9]Huang HM, Liaw SS, Lai CM, Exploring learner acceptance of the use of virtual reality in medical education: A case study of desktop and projection-based display systems Interactive Learning Environments 2016 24(1):03-19.10.1080/10494820.2013.817436  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]

[10]Lim KH, Loo ZY, Goldie SJ, Adams JW, McMenamin PG, Use of 3D printed models in medical education: A randomized control trial comparing 3D prints versus cadaveric materials for learning external cardiac anatomy Anatomical Sciences Education 2016 9(3):213-21.10.1002/ase.157326468636  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[11]Fonseca D, Martí N, Redondo E, Navarro I, Sánchez A, Relationship between student profile, tool use, participation, and academic performance with the use of Augmented Reality technology for visualized architecture models Computers in Human Behavior 2014 31:434-45.10.1016/j.chb.2013.03.006  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]

[12]Gulek JC, Demirtas H, Learning with technology: The impact of laptop use on student achievement The journal of Technology, Learning and Assessment 2005 3(2)Retrieved from: https://ejournals.bc.edu/index.php/jtla/article/view/1655  [Google Scholar]

[13]Valle J, Godby T, Paul III DP, Smith H, Coustasse A, Use of smartphones for clinical and medical education The Health Care Manager 2017 36(3):293-300.10.1097/HCM.000000000000017628738399  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[14]Gavali MY, Khismatrao DS, Gavali YV, Patil KB, Smartphone, the new learning aid amongst medical students Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research: JCDR 2017 11(5):JC0510.7860/JCDR/2017/20948.982628658804  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[15]Lewis TL, Burnett B, Tunstall RG, Abrahams PH, Complementing anatomy education using three-dimensional anatomy mobile software applications on tablet computers Clinical Anatomy 2014 27(3):313-20.10.1002/ca.2225623661327  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]  [PubMed]

[16]Malaney GD, Student use of the internet Journal of Educational Technology Systems 2005 33(1):53-66.10.2190/VQRQ-YQX6-ARKL-7D2T  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]

[17]Senthil V, Does the more internet usage provide good academic grades? Education and Information Technologies 2018 23(6):2901-10.10.1007/s10639-018-9749-8  [Google Scholar]  [CrossRef]