Do Nascimento et al., [9] In vitro | Revolution Implant; SIN / n=30 | External hexagon | 32 Ncm/Non loaded | 7 days | 13 bacterial species | IAI | DNA Checkerboard/ Culture | Commonly C. gingivalis and S.mutans were found to harbour the internal surface of the implants. |
Harder S et al., [10] In vitro | Cone-log implants; Straumann Implant/n=20 | Conical implant abutment connection | Recommended by manufacturer/ Unloaded | 1 h, 8 h, 24 h | S. enterica | IAI | Real time quantitative PCR and Immunoassay | Conical implant-abutment connections do not prevent microleakage on amolecular level. |
Park S et al., [11] In vitro | GS II RBM Fixture; Osstem Implant/n=40 | Internal hexagon | 20 Ncm/16000 times | 7 days | 0.5% Solution of basic fuchsin | Access holes of implant prosthesis retained with screw. | Spectrop- hotometer | The microleakage was reduced when the access holes were sealed with gutta- percha or vinyl polysiloxane. |
Rismanchian M et al., [1] In vitro | ITI implants/ n=36 | Cast on, castable, solid, and synocta abutments | 35 Ncm/Static condition | 5 h-14 days | E. coli | IAI | Scanning electron microscope | Premachined titanium abutments reduce the amount of microgap when compared with cast on and castable abutments. |
Baggi L et al., [12] In vitro | Dentsply Friadent, Astra Tech AG, GTB, Mega’ Gen, Straumann, Nobel Biocare / n=120 | Tube-in-tube interface; Flat-to-flat interface | 15-35N/ Static condition | 7 days | S. sanguinis, F. nucleatum, A. odontolyticus, C. albicans, C. glabrata | IAI | Culture and scanning electron microscopy | Tube-in-tube interface implants were more resistant to colonization. Torque value suggested by manufacturer showed less colonization than lower torques given manually. |
Giorgini G et al., [13] In vitro | -------- | Locking tapered connection | -------- | 24 h | Bacteria | IAI and the implant- healing cap interface | X-ray micro- tomography | Hermetic barrier against microbial leakage was provided by implant-healing cap tapered connection |
Cavusoglu Y et al., [14] In vitro | Straumann implant/n=10 | Zi abutment/ Ti implant interface; Ti abutment/ Ti implant interface. | 35 Ncm/ 500 000 cycles | -------- | Acrylic resin | IAI | SEM with X-ray microanalysis | In loaded condition Zi abutment/Ti implant interface shows microleakage approaching the screw joint. The integrity of the implant abutment interface was compromised by difference in material. |
Koutouzis T et al., [15] In vitro | Custom Dental Implants/ n=40 | Internal Morse-taper connection. | 25 Ncm/500000 cycles | 5 days | E. coli | IAI | Colony forming units (CFU) were counted. | Morse-taper connection showed minimal penetration of bacteria down to the IAI. Penetration of bacteria increased on dynamic loading |
Nayak AG et al., [16] In vitro | ADIN Dental Implant Systems/ n=45 | Unsealed group, sealed with O-rings, sealed with gap Seal gel. | 20 N/ Static condition | 5 days | Enterococcus | IAI | Digital colony counter | Least growth was observed in the gap seal group followed by the O-ring group. When more torque was used and less leakage has been observed |
Sahin C et al., [17] In vitro | Medical Instinct; EZ, Megagen Implant/ n=3 | Intenal hex Ti, Internal hex Zi, Morse tapered Ti | 25 Nm/ Static loading | 20 min | Deionized water | IAI | Modified fluid filtration method | Higher microleakage was observed at the implant- internal hex Zi abutment. |
Smith NA and Turkyilmaz I [18] In vitro | Nobel Replace / n=46 | External hexagon | 20 Ncm and 35 Ncm/ Static condition | Daily evaluation was done till leakage was observed. | P. intermedia, P. gingivalis, F. nucleatum | IAI | Electronic colony counter | Smaller microgap was observed in implant with titanium abutment than implant with zirconia abutment. Increase of torque from 20 Ncm to 35 Ncm decreases the microgap of zirconia abutment. |
Verdugo CL et al., [19] In vitro | MG Mozo-Grau Osseous/n=42 | External connection; Conical internal connection (Morse taper) | 20 N and 30 N | 24 hour | 0.2% methylene blue | IAI | Optical microscopy | Less microleakage was shown by Morse taper connection implants then external connection implants; Increase torque decreases the microleakage. |
Abdelhamed MI et al., [20] In vitro | Astratech- implants/n=32 | Implant with Titanium (Ti) and Zirconia (Zi) abutments | 15 Ncm and 25 Ncm/Static condition | 5 minutes, 25 h, and 195 h. | E. coli | IAI | Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) test and Toluidine blue dye penetration test | At 15 Ncm torque microleakage of Zi was higher with time when compared with Ti; Zi when torqued at 15 Ncm showed higher microleakage with time in comparison to Zi torqued at 25 Ncm. |
Al-Jadaa A et al., [21] In vitro | Astra Tech (A), Biomet 3i (B); Nobel Biocare (C))/ n=30 | Taper lock and internal hexagonal (A); Flat-to-flat interface and internal hexagonal mating surface (B); Flat-to-flat and a trilobe mating (C) | Group A and Group B 20 Ncm and Group C 35 Ncm; Static and dynamic loading 1’200’000 cycles | 2 days | Bacteria | IAI | Gas Enhanced Permeation Test (GEPT) | Best leakage resistance was shown by group B under static and dynamic conditions. |
Canullo L et al., [22] Human Study | Biome T3i, Premium- Kohno, Astra Tech / n=80 | External hexagon double internal hexagon; Internal hexagon with external collar; Conical connection. | Functionally loaded | 5 yrs | A. actinomyc- etemcomitans, P. gingivalis, T. forsythensis, T. denticola, P. intermedia, P. micros, F. nucleatum, Campylobacter rectus, Eikenell- acorrodens, C. albicans | Connection’s inside and the abutment surface (CIAS) | Quantitative realtime PCR | Microleakage was not prevented at IAI by any design of connections. At the peri-implant sulcus and inside the connection less bacterial leakage was shown by internal hexagon with external collar and conical connection. |
D’Ercole S et al., [23] In vitro | -------- | Two different implant connections. | -------- | 14 days | E. faecalis; A. actinomy- cetemcomitans | IAI | Scanning electron microscopy | No leakages through the I-A interface were demonstrated for either type of connection evaluated. |
Dias Resende CC et al., [24] In vitro | Neodent/ n=30 | Morse taper | 32 Ncm and 15 Ncm/ Static condition | 7 and 30 days | S. sanguinis, F. nucleatum | Micro- leakage from the inner part and microl- eakage in to the inner part of implant | Turbidimetry test | When the prosthetic index changed, sealing of the Morse taper junction is efficient and there was lower microleakage under static conditions. |
Do Nascimento C et al., [25] In vitro | Duo system and Duoconsystem/ n=48 | External hex (EH) /Morse cone (MC) | 20 Ncm / 500000 cycles | -------- | 38 bacterial species including (P. gingivalis, T. forsythia, T. Denticola); 5 Candida species | IAI | Checkerboard DNA-DNA hybridization | Higher microbial count was found in EH implants than MC implants. Colonization of microorganisms was not found at the internal surfaces of MC implants. |
Ranieri R et al., [26] In vitro | Morse taper system/ n=4 | Internal hex | 25 Ncm, 20 Ncm, 32 Ncm/ Static loading | 48 h | S. sanguinis | IAI | Scanning electron microscopy | Morse taper implant system does not provide resistance to bacterial leakage at IAI. |
Tripodi D et al., [27] In vitro | Cone Morse taper/ n=20 | Internal connection | 500,000 cycles | 14 days | E. faecalis | IAI | Histological method | Both unloaded and dynamic loading do not show any differences in the microbial leakage. |
Alves DCC et al., [28] In vitro | Morse taper implants and tapered screwed implants / n=48 | Internal conical screw less connection; Tapered screw-retained implant prosthesis | 20 Ncm/ 500,000 cycles | 14 days | E. coli | IAI | Scanning electron microscopy | There was no effective sealing of tapered implant/ abutment. Effective sealing was not obtained due to imprecise machining of implant parts. |
Gherlone EF et al., [29] In vitro | Bicon, Astra Tech, Biosafin, Sweden e Martina/ n=80 | Morse locking taper; Conical connection, Internal hexagonon; Internal connection, double taper | Torque used as recommended by manufacturer/ Static condition. | 1h, 3 h, 6h, 16 h, 24 h, 48 h, 72h and 96 h | E. coli | IAI | Bacterial growth evaluation | Internal connection, double taper at 96 hours showed less bacterial microleakage when compared to other internal connections. |
Guerra E et al., [30] In vitro | Easy grip, Connect AR, AR Torq/ n=150 | Internal hexagon, External hexagon, Morse taper | 20 Ncm/Static loading | 14 days | E. coli, S. sanguinis | IAI | Scanning electron microscopy | No difference in bacterial leakage was found among different implant abutment connections. |
Khorshidi H et al., [31] In vitro | CSM Implants and TBR Implants/ n=20 | 11 degree internal Morse Connection; Butt joint connection | 30 N-cm/ Static condition | 14 days | S. mutans | IAI | Colony count and turbidity | Morse taper implant showed more resistance to microbial leakage in comparison to butt joint implants. |
Koutouzis T et al., [32] In vitro | Morse taper system Astra Tech / n=40 | Conventional margin, Sloped margin design | 25 Ncm torque/ 500,000 cycles | 5 days | E. coli | IAI | Colony forming units (CFU) were counted | Under dynamic loading sloped marginal design implants showed same bacterial invasion at IAI as conventional marginal design implants. |
Mencio F et al., [33] In vitro | n=12 | Screwed connection; Cemented connection | -------- | 14 days | Bacterial species | IAI | PCR-Real time analysis | In both the connections bacterial species penetrated at IAI; The lowest bacterial penetration was shown at cemented connection implants. |
Peruzetto WM et al., [34] In vitro | Morse taper system/ n= 22 | Tapered implant connections with indexed and non indexed abutments | 20 N | 14 days | E. coli | IAI | Microbiological analysis | No adequate sealing against bacterial leakage was shown by both tapered components. A superior seal was shown by indexed type components. |
Pita MS et al., [35] In vitro | EH - Biodent HEX RP; TI Bioneck TRI RP/ n=48 | External hexagon; Tri-channel internal connection | 32 Ncm/ Unloaded | 7 days | 35 bacterial species and 3 Candida species | IAI | Checkerboard DNA-DNA hybridization | In both the external (EH) and internal (TI) connections large number of microbial species penetrated at IAI; Implants attached with conical head abutment screws showed less microorganisms in comparison to conventional flat-head screws. |
Wachtel A et al., [2] In vitro | Perio Type Rapid Implants/ n=7 | An internal octagonal butt joint | 30 Ncm/ 1000000 cycles | 24 h | E. faecium | IAI | Kanamycin- Aesculnazide Agar (KAAA), as optical indicator for E. faecium | Three implants showed bacterial leakage under static condition. At low number of load cycles bacterial leakage occurred in other implants. |
Zipprich H [36] In vitro | Fourteen implant systems/ n=70 | Conical and flat implant abutment connection. | As recommended by manufacturers/ 1200000 cycles | 15 min | S. sanguinis, S. mutans, A. viscosus, F. nucleatum, V. parvula | IAI | Florescence microscopy | Under static loading bacterial contamination was not observed. Under dynamic loading conical implant abutment connection offers better seal. |